Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Andrew Coyne, First past the post sets Canada up for secession threats.

Andrew Coyne, First past the post sets Canada up for secession threats.
Globe and Mail, Oct. 13: 

``We have an electoral system that seems almost purpose-built to divide us.

Albertans complain that they have not been listened to. In the last election, for example, the Liberals won 28 per cent of the vote in Alberta, their best showing since 1968. Yet they still won just two of the province’s 37 seats. Whereas the Liberals have been able to win a majority of the seats in Quebec or Ontario with as little as 36 per cent and 39 per cent of the vote respectively.

Suppose, instead, we had a system in which a party’s share of the seats more closely resembled its share of the popular vote. Then not only would every party be able to win seats across the country – every party would have to do so, to have any hope of governing.

We would at last have a truly national politics. No longer would it be possible to play one region off against another. Parties would have to appeal to the whole country at the same time.``

With 11 Liberal MPs, Liberals could have gotten 3 of the 29 cabinet ministers not just one, reflecting Alberta’s 10.8% of Canada’s MPs.

So let`s look at Alberta’s 37 MPs who would have been elected in 2025 under proportional representation.

What PR model should we use for this projection?

The new federal NDP PR policy says “a made-in-Canada model of mixed member PR that is regionally-based and ensures local representation using a combination of single-member and/or multi-member districts, combined with top-up seats as required to ensure proportionality.”

Plan A (MMP): 22 local single-member districts combined with 15 top-up seats (regional or province-wide) as required to ensure proportionality.

Plan B (Regional-Mixed-Member): a combination of single-member (8) and multi-member districts (4), combined with top-up seats as required (3) to ensure proportionality: single-member ridings as may be deemed appropriate in rural and “small-urban” areas involving cities and towns of less than 100,000 residents.

Plan A (with 2 regions):

In the 2025 election, in the 19 ridings of South Alberta, Conservative voters cast 66.0% of the three-party vote, entitling them to elect 12 MPs (10 local, 2 regional) not 18; Liberal voters cast 30.3% of the votes, entitling them to elect 6 MPs (1 local, 5 regional) not just one; and NDP voters cast 3.7% of the voters, entitling them to elect one regional MP not none. In the 18 ridings of North Alberta, Conservative voters cast 63.9% of the three-party vote, entitling them to elect 11 MPs (9 local, 2 regional) not 16; Liberal voters cast 26.6% of the votes entitling them to elect 5 MPs (1 local, 4 regional) not just one; and NDP voters cast 9.5% of the votes entitling them to elect 2 MPs (1 local, 1 regional) not just one.

The regional MPs would have been the regional candidates who got the most votes on the regional open lists. (P.S. By using two regions for this projection, the NDP picks up a bonus of 1 from the Conservatives, so the total is 23 Conservative MPs, 11 Liberals, 3 NDP.)

Plan B:

In the Calgary Census Metropolitan Area (including Airdrie-Cochrane), with 12 MPs, this region would have elected 11 MPs (7 Conservatives, 4 Liberals), shrunk by 1 to allow for 3 top-up MPs. In Edmonton CMA (including Edmonton Sherwood Park-Fort Saskatchewan, St. Albert-Sturgeon River, Parkland, and Leduc-Wetaskiwin), with 13 MPs, this region would have elected 12 MPs (7 Conservatives, 4 Liberals, 1 NDP), again shrunk by 1 to allow for 3 top-up MPs. In Lethbridge-Medicine Hat, the 2 MPs would have been one Conservative and 1 Liberal. In Red Deer-Ponoka both the 2 MPs would have been Conservatives. In the 8 single member ridings, shrunk to 7 to allow for 3 top-up MPs, 7 Conservative MPs. The three top-up MPs are 2 Liberals and 1 NDP. Total: 24 Conservative MPs, 11 Liberals, 2 NDP.

Of course, this is only a simulation. In any election, as Prof. Dennis Pilon says: "Now keep in mind that, when you change the voting system, you also change the incentives that affect the kinds of decisions that voters might make. For instance, we know that, when every vote counts, voters won't have to worry about splitting the vote, or casting a strategic vote. Thus, we should expect that support for different parties might change."

(P.S. FVC`s website on Regional-Mixed-Member says voters elect MPs from multi-member ridings by making a mark next to one candidate of their choice from a party's list. A vote for a candidate counts as a vote for that candidate`s party. Like this ballot that PEI voters chose in their 2016 plebiscite. It links to FVC`s submission to the ERRE:
https://www.fairvote.ca/19/08/2016/fvc-erre-submissions_appx_12_-rural-urban_pr/

It explains “Rural-Urban PR uses single-member ridings as may be deemed appropriate in rural and “small-urban” areas involving cities and towns of less than 100,000 residents.” A table says 5-25% of the MPs would be from single-member districts.  Regional MPs (top up seats) could be elected by best runners up (the best performing local candidates in the region who did not get a local seat) or a second ballot with an open list could be used.

Singles would not be Lethbridge (metro 123,847), so add Medicine Hat-Cardston-Warner. Nor Red Deer: city and CMA 100,844, so add Ponoka-Didsbury (note: Lacombe city 13,396, County 10,283). 

Saturday, May 23, 2026

Is Alberta being heard in Ottawa?

Competing Alberta groups complain they are not being heard in Ottawa. Of course, the underlying problem is, many of them are right. If every vote counted, they would all be heard.

In 2025 Alberta voters elected 37 MPs. Counting voters for parties that won at least 5% of Alberta votes, if every vote counted they would have elected 11 Liberal MPs not just two, two NDP MPs not just one, and 24 Conservative MPs rather than 34.

In 2021 Alberta voters elected 34 MPs. If every vote counted, they would have elected five Liberal MPs not just two, seven NDP MPs not just two, three Peoples Party MPs rather than zero, and 19 Conservative MPs rather than 30.

In 2025 Metro Calgary’s 12 MPs would have included four Liberals, not just Corey Hogan, with three top-up MPs from Calgary, the Liberal candidates who got the most votes.  Similarly, Metro Edmonton’s 12 MPs would have included four Liberals, not just Eleanor Olszewski, with three top-up MPs from Edmonton, the Liberal candidates who got the most votes. Southern Alberta’s seven MPs would have included two regional Liberal MPs from top-up seats, just as Northern Alberta’s six MPs would have included a regional top-up Liberal MP. And NDP voters would have elected a second NDP MP, maybe Keira Gunn from Calgary.

Alberta should have three cabinet ministers in a 30-member cabinet, not just one. With 11 Liberal MPs from Alberta, they could have had three cabinet members.

In 2021 Metro Calgary’s 11 MPs would have included two Liberals, not just George Chahal, with a regional top-up MP. Metro Edmonton’s 11 MPs would have included two Liberals, not just Randy Boissonnault, with a regional top-up MP. Southern Alberta’s 6 MPs would have included a Liberal regional MP like Devon Hargreaves from Lethbridge. The NDP did better in 2021, so Metro Edmonton NDP voters would have elected one regional top-up MP as well as Heather McPherson and Blake Desjarlais, while NDP voters in Metro Calgary would have elected two regional MPs, plus one in Southern Alberta and one In Northern Alberta. The Peoples Party of Canada got 7.3% of the Alberta votes in 2021, giving them one Calgary MP such as Jonathan Hagel, one Edmonton MP such as Murray MacKinnon, and one from Northen Alberta such as Michael Manchen.

A national poll of Canadians asking about support for proportional representation was conducted by EKOS Research Associates between January 22-29, 2025. 68% of Canadians support moving to proportional representation, with only 19% opposed and 13% unsure.

At an event during the last election, Mark Carney explained that electoral reform was not in the Liberal platform because they are focused on addressing the economic crisis, but suggested that they may pursue a process for electoral reform after the economic crisis had abated.

This simulation uses the Mixed Member Proportional system that was recommended by the Law Commission of Canada. As Prof. Dennis Pilon says: "We know that, when every vote counts, voters won't have to worry about splitting the vote, or casting a strategic vote. Thus, we should expect that support for different parties might change.” With open-list, the ballot would look like this ballot that PEI voters chose in their 2016 plebiscite. With two votes, you can vote for a candidate of the party you want in government. And you can also vote for the local candidate you like best regardless of party, without hurting your party, since it's the second (regional) ballot that determines the party make-up of Parliament. About 32% of voters split their ballots this way in New Zealand with a similar system. This makes it easier for local MPs to get the support of people of all political stripes. They can earn support for their constituency-representation credentials, not just for their party. This boosts the kind of support MPs bring with them into the House of Commons, thus strengthening their independence. This is the system used in Germany and, with regions like Canada would want, in Scotland.

Who should design an electoral system? A Citizens Assembly on Electoral Reform could do an impartial job of designing a PR system, if they are asked to.

Wednesday, January 21, 2026

What would an election in Canada today give us under proportional representation?

What would an election in Canada today give us under proportional representation?

On current Canadian polls the Conservative vote has dropped from 41.3% last April to 36.6%, the NDP vote has partly recovered from 6.3% to 10.2%, the Liberal vote has declined from 43.8% to 39.9%, the Bloc vote has climbed from 6.3% to 7.6%, and the Green vote has recovered from 1.2% to 3.3%.

If Canada had proportional representation, adjusting the numbers of votes cast in April by current polls (assuming nation-wide swings), Liberal voters would have elected 142 MPs, Conservatives 130 MPs, New Democrats 38 MPs, Bloc voters 26 MPs, and Green voters 7 MPs. (I am using a model calculated with province-wide proportionality but with regional representation in regions averaging 23 MPs in the four larger provinces; not large enough to elect any People’s Party candidates.)

I have already posted a report on the outcome of the 2025 election on the votes as cast with proportional representation. It showed 40% top-up MPs was enough for fully proportional results.

With 343 MPs, a bill needs 172 votes to pass, so the Liberals would need to work with the 38 NDP MPs (or else with a combination of Bloc and Green MPs), unlike the current House of Commons where the Bloc has a veto, since every bill must go through a Standing Committee where a Bloc member holds the balance of power.

Even with fewer votes by current polls, the Liberal caucus would be more representative than today: 10 MPs from Alberta not just 2, 4 MPs from Saskatchewan not just 1, 9 MPs from Southwest Ontario not just 5, 6 from Northern and Central Ontario not just 5, and 8 from Eastern and Central Quebec not just 6. Similarly, the Conservative caucus would be more representative than today: 6 MPs from Montréal-Laval-Montérégie not zero, 3 MPs from Mauricie-Lanaudière-Laurentides-nord-ouest not zero, 13 MPs from Toronto and York not just 9, 4 MPs from Nova Scotia not just 1, 2 MPs from PEI not zero, and 9 MPs from the BC Lower Mainland not just 7.

The NDP would elect 10 MPs from Ontario, 9 from BC, 6 from Quebec, 4 from Alberta, 3 from Manitoba, 2 from Saskatchewan, 1 from New Brunswick, 1 from Nova Scotia, and 1 from Newfoundland and Labrador.

My calculation assumes the conventional Mixed Member Proportional model supported by the NDP ever since its 2003 convention when, to the amazement of the media, in the middle of electing Jack Layton as leader the delegates debated proportional representation on the convention floor and adopted an amendment to set a threshold of 5% for parties to elect some regional MPs to top-up seats, while still electing the majority of MPs from local ridings. With 60% local MPs, a group of five local ridings would become three larger ridings. (My current calculation assumes no legal threshold, since regions averaging 23 MPs, would normally exclude such smaller parties. The Green Party would still elect 4 MPs in Ontario and 3 in BC.)

At an event during the last election, Mark Carney explained that electoral reform was not in the Liberal platform because they are focused on addressing the economic crisis, but suggested that they may pursue a process for electoral reform after the economic crisis had abated. The last Liberal Convention adopted a resolution ”that the Liberal Party of Canada urge the Government of Canada to establish a non-partisan National Citizens’ Assembly on Electoral Reform to continue the work started in 2014.”.

The NDP PR Policy as amended at the 2013 convention in 2023:

New Democrats believe in:
a          Reforming Canada’s electoral system through mixed member proportional representation.
b          Prioritizing electoral reform based on a citizens’ consensus for change and a transparent parliamentary committee process to convene a citizens’ assembly on electoral reform. 

The Mixed Member Proportional system was recommended by the Law Commission of Canada. As Prof. Dennis Pilon says: "We know that, when every vote counts, voters won't have to worry about splitting the vote, or casting a strategic vote. Thus, we should expect that support for different parties might change.” With open-list, the ballot would look like this ballot that PEI voters chose in their 2016 plebiscite. With two votes, you can vote for the party you want in government. And you can also vote for the local candidate you like best regardless of party, without hurting your party, since it's the second (regional) ballot that determines the party make-up of Parliament. About 32% of voters split their ballots this way in New Zealand with a similar system. This makes it easier for local MPs to get the support of people of all political stripes. They can earn support for their constituency-representation credentials, not just for their party. This boosts the kind of support MPs bring with them into the House of Commons, thus strengthening their independence. This is the system used in Germany and, with regions like Canada would want, in Scotland.